As healthcare advances, employers have an opportunity to look beyond what’s new and focus on what delivers meaningful value for employees.
We’re surrounded by innovation. New technologies promise to save time, simplify our lives, and deliver better results. But how often do we stop to ask whether the latest improvement is actually making things better?
It’s an important question in healthcare, where advances in medications, treatments, and technology can transform lives — but often introduce significant costs and greater complexity.
A recent conversation with one of our business partners brought this into focus. We discussed an economic concept highlighted in William Baumol’s book, The Cost Disease: Why Computers Get Cheaper and Health Care Doesn’t.
The basic idea is that costs in labor-intensive industries like healthcare can continue rising even when productivity doesn’t increase at the same pace as in industries where technology makes it easier to produce more with fewer resources.
Consider manufacturing, where technology can dramatically improve efficiency. Healthcare, however, still depends on highly trained professionals, time, expertise, and human interaction. While advances in medicine and technology have improved countless lives, they haven’t necessarily made healthcare more affordable.
That raises a question worth considering: With so much innovation in healthcare, how do we distinguish between advances that deliver meaningful, lasting value and those that simply add cost and complexity?
The Value of Staying Power
Let's step outside healthcare for a moment and consider products and innovations that have stood the test of time. A trusty Speed Queen washing machine with simple controls. A basic vacuum cleaner that's been a household workhorse for decades.
Sen. Chuck Grassley made news this summer when his nearly 50-year-old Hoover vacuum, affectionately named Beth, was finally retired after an electrical malfunction. The vacuum had served his family for nearly five decades.
Then there’s the three-point seat belt, introduced by Volvo. A relatively simple innovation that has saved countless lives and remains one of the most important safety features in automobiles today.
There's something to be said for that kind of reliability. Healthcare offers its own example: penicillin. Discovered by Alexander Fleming in 1928 and developed into a widely available treatment in the 1940s, penicillin changed the course of medicine. Infections that once threatened lives became treatable. Nearly a century after its discovery, penicillin remains an effective treatment for certain bacterial infections.
Think about that. An innovation that transformed healthcare generations ago continues to deliver meaningful results today.
Medicine hasn’t stood still. New medications, therapies and technologies have made advances possible, and we should continue to pursue them. But penicillin reminds us that a breakthrough doesn’t lose its value simply because something newer comes along.
These examples share something important. Their value isn’t determined by how sophisticated they are or how recently they were introduced. It’s demonstrated by what they accomplish and how well those results hold up over time.
That brings us back to healthcare. We know the value of preventive care, early intervention, strong primary care relationships, and effective chronic disease management. These aren’t new ideas, yet they remain fundamental to better health.
The challenge is making sure they are accessible and individuals benefit from them.
Better results do not always come from creating something new. Sometimes they come from helping employees make better use of the healthcare choices they already have.
>>Take Action: Before adding another healthcare program or solution, take a closer look at the investments you’ve already made. Are employees benefiting from proven approaches to prevention and chronic disease management? Are there opportunities to improve access, engagement or outcomes? Sometimes the greatest value comes from making what already works work better.
Proof of Progress
Employers are constantly evaluating new benefits, technologies, programs and partnerships. Each promises something valuable: better health outcomes, lower costs, improved access, or a simpler employee experience. But promises are not results.
With so many solutions entering the healthcare marketplace, we need to look beyond what’s new and ask tougher questions. What problem are we trying to solve? What evidence supports the proposed solution? How will it improve the employee experience? What outcomes can we reasonably expect? And how will we know whether it’s working?
We also need to consider complexity. Does a new solution make it easier for employees to get appropriate care, or does it introduce another program, platform, or decision they must navigate?
Think about an employee managing a chronic condition. Adding another digital tool or benefit may sound appealing, but it creates another login, another set of instructions or another disconnected resource. Have we really made that person’s healthcare experience better? On the other hand, a solution that helps that same employee connect with the right provider, better manage their condition, or avoid unnecessary care may deliver value without relying on groundbreaking technology.
That's why we need to measure healthcare investments by more than cost alone.
>>Take Action: As you evaluate new healthcare solutions, define what success looks like before making the investment. Ask for credible evidence, establish measurable expectations, and hold your partners accountable for results. Consider clinical outcomes, employee experience, accessibility, and total cost of care. Make sure you revisit the measures over time to determine whether the investment is delivering the results you expected.
A Promising Path Forward
Innovation is essential to improving healthcare. Advances in treatments, diagnostic tools, and disease management have transformed patient care, and we should continue supporting approaches that improve outcomes and bring better care to the people who need it.
But innovation does not always mean replacing what came before. Sometimes it means building on what’s proven, improving how existing resources are used or finding simpler ways to achieve better results. At Health Action Council, we believe employers have an important role in asking the right questions, sharing knowledge, and challenging assumptions about how healthcare value is measured. By working together, we can identify approaches that improve health outcomes while making healthcare more affordable and accessible.
The next healthcare innovation may be a breakthrough treatment, a new technology, or an entirely different way of delivering care. Or it may be finding a better way to use something we’ve had all along.
Our responsibility is not to predict which innovations will stand the test of time. It’s to ask the right questions, demand evidence, and measure the results that matter.
The true measure of innovation is not how much we change. It’s how much we improve. That’s innovation with purpose. Let's continue the conversation.
About the author
Patty Starr
Patty Starr is president and CEO of Health Action Council and is responsible for driving the strategic direction of the organization--build stronger, healthier communities where business can thrive.